BitterSweet

An Obsession with All Things Handmade and Home-Cooked

Hop On Over

74 Comments

What’s sweet, minty, and green all over? Don’t worry, it’s not the set up for a bad joke, but a grasshopper pie! With roots going back only to the 60’s, it’s a relative new comer on the pie scene, and yet no one is quite sure where the name came from. I might speculate that it’s “green as a grasshopper,” but then why didn’t they call it frog pie, or Calyptomena viridis pie? Not as catchy? No, I can’t imagine that’s the reason… It was allegedly said that “dinner guests sometimes click their heels with glee over a superb dessert,” but if that were the case, why aren’t there more grasshopper desserts? Wouldn’t we all be clicking our heels over every molten chocolate cake that crosses our lips?

Anyway, enough silliness, because this is one serious pie. Fortified with a splash of creme de mènthe and chilled, it’s a nostalgic adult treat that absolutely screams summer. Traditionally composed of marshmallows and cool whip, it’s one recipe that was all but off limits until recently, but all that has changed thanks to the brilliant Chicago Soy Dairy. Now that vegan marshmallows are more abundant, I can even justify using a whole bag in one recipe!

My take on grasshopper pie has some significant differences from the original, however- Most notably, mine gets its bulk and lovely green hue thanks to some creamy avocados, not artificial whipped topping or nasty green dye. Freezing it makes for a truly refreshing treat, and gives it the added bonus of being stable enough to make popsicles out of. Pi-sicles, if you will. Yes, you heard me right- Frozen grasshopper pie on a stick, dipped in chocolate!

What are you waiting for? This a pie that belongs on your summer menu, one way or another!

Frozen Grasshopper Pie

Chocolate Crust:

1 1/2 Cups Chocolate Cookie Crumbs (15 Chocolate Sandwich Cookies)
5 Tablespoons Margarine, Melted

Mint Filling:

1 Cup Pureed Avocado (From About 2 Small, Ripe Avocados)
1 Teaspoon Lemon Juice
1/4 Cup Crème de Menthe*
1 10-Ounce Package Dandies Marshmallows
1/4 Teaspoon Salt
1/2 Teaspoon Peppermint Extract
1/2 Teaspoon Vanilla Extract

*To make this pie kid-friendly, replace the alcohol with 1/4 cup plain soymilk and 1 teaspoon peppermint extract.

Begin by combining the cookie crumbs and melted margarine in a large bowl, and stir well until there are no dry spots. Transfer this mixture to a 9-inch round pie tin, and use your fingers to press it evenly across the bottom and up the sides. Place the crust in your freezer until firm, at least 30 minutes.

Meanwhile, you can start preparing the filling. Puree your avocado using a blender or food processor, along with the lemon juice and crème de menthe. Scrape down the sides of the bowl periodically ensure you have no lumps of avocado. Set aside.

Place all of the marshmallows in a medium sauce pan, and set it over moderate heat. Stir continuously until the marshmallows have completely melted, and quickly transfer the marshmallow goo into your food processor or blender. Pulse to combine, and add in the salt, mint, and vanilla extract. Scrape down the sides once or twice between pulses, until the mixture is homogeneous. Pour into your frozen crust, and return the whole thing to the freezer. Let freeze for at least 4 hours, until set and sliceable. If desired, top with chocolate shavings, curls, or ganache. Alternately, cut into 8 slices, insert lollipop or popsicle sticks into the side crust, and dip in homemade magic shell (a double batch will cover the whole pie nicely and leave you with plenty leftover for other ice cream treats.)

Serves 8 – 10

Printable Recipe

Author: Hannah (BitterSweet)

Author of My Sweet Vegan, Vegan Desserts, Vegan a la Mode, and Easy as Vegan Pie.

74 thoughts on “Hop On Over

  1. ohyumyumyum.

    xo
    kittee

    Like

  2. Oh my that is sheer brilliance, Hannah! I am definitely inspired to make this by your beautiful photos, with some tweaks to decarb it. I can’t believe that green hue is all natural. Fabulous!

    Like

  3. wow that is impressive!
    it looks sooo good.

    Like

  4. Oh my gosh, what are you doing to us posting recipes like this! LOL :)
    It looks so delicious, your such a fantastic cook! and photographer.

    Rose

    Like

  5. OMG, Frozen grasshopper pie covered in chocolate using avocados? Brilliant!! Hannah, you rock, as does everything you make!

    Like

  6. Oh wow! Yum. I love anything minty.

    Like

  7. Ooooh! I love it! The colors are gorgeous and I can just imagine how refreshing it would be to snack on one of these beauties during the sweltering summer heat. Perfect treat, well done, as always!

    Like

  8. Awesome! You never cease to amaze me, Hannah… Can’t wait to get home to try these!!

    Like

  9. Whoa, I was reading through and thinking “yeah, cool, grasshopper pie…” and then “holy s*** grasshopper pie *on a stick!* *dipped in chocolate!*” You just made my morning :)

    Like

  10. I totally have to make that pie! I love how you used avocado. YUMMY!

    Like

  11. I love the natural coloring- it looks simply perfect :)

    Like

  12. Pie on a stick! What a fantastic idea!

    Like

  13. Absolutely stunning presentation… as usual.
    Elena

    Like

  14. Chocolate Covered Grasshopper Pie on a Stick!?? WOW! Looks great!

    Like

  15. An avocado??? Love it!! And dipped in chocolate… you won my heart with this one for sure :) Now I just need another PPQ invite so I can make this to bring!

    Like

  16. YUM, i haven’t had this in forever but something tells me i need to make it again now :)

    Like

  17. I still haven’t tried Dandies marshmallows. A frozen marshmallow pie with such a fresh-looking color is heavenly. Thanks for sharing the recipe! It’s really beautiful!

    Like

  18. Oh my gosh- what an amazing dessert! As if the pie doesn’t sound good enough, dipping it in chocolate must make it over the top!

    Like

  19. This looks amazing. I’m surprised you got such a perfect color just from using avocados.

    Like

  20. I love the chocolate covered slices, those are adorable! And delicious!

    Like

  21. Yum! And thanks for the link to the homemade magic shell. My partner loves the stuff but I can not abide by the junk they use in the commercial crap. This is perfect!

    Like

  22. I don’t even know what to say!

    Like

  23. That sounds a lot like a certain concoction you helped me with for Go Dairy Free several months back! Love the use of creme de menthe, looks great.

    Like

  24. Chocolate-covered pie-sicles? YES! That absolutely makes my day.

    Like

  25. …..

    I really don’t even know what to say, that looks amazing. Want to come bring me one?

    Like

  26. ooh this looks like the ULTIMATE summer dessert!

    Like

  27. That looks super good! I wish I had one right now :)

    Like

  28. YUM! I love the drink. I’ll have to try the pie.

    Like

  29. It’s no secret that I don’t eat avocado, but this pie looks divine! I believe I’ve always wondered what Grasshopper Pie was and I’m happy to know now.

    Like

  30. Sounds wonderful! And I love the pie-pops–think those will be my version to try!

    Like

  31. Oh GOSH!!! A work of art, a simply amazing concoction. I was directed here by @jo_jo_ba via Twitter. Thanks for sharing this! wow

    Like

  32. Agggh this looks SO insanely good!! I want a pi-sicle!

    Like

  33. pi-sicles!!! LOVE that. the pie looks so good! My old housemate had this rancid old bottle of creme de menthe for years that never got touched – now I pity it. Maybe it just wanted to be made into pie!

    Like

  34. You are such an amazing talent! These are beautiful.

    Like

  35. Mmm! Hannah, these look fantastic! I’ve been really into adding avocado into things lately, so this is another exciting recipe to try. It looks lovely and refreshing!

    Like

  36. Frozen grasshopper pies on a stick?? WOW!

    Like

  37. Sweetened Avocado filling …covered in chocolate …on a stick… I’ll have three please!

    Like

  38. oh my goodness hannah!
    looks soooo beautiful. I’ve never had grasshopper pie, but it sounds great. I love the chocolate dipped wedges. That’s just crazy!!
    :)

    Like

  39. now that’s one awesome pie.

    Like

  40. Wow, mint and chocolate…really yummie!

    Like

  41. Can you taste the avocado? That seems like such a weird combination, mint, chocolate, and avocado. I might have to make this just to see how it tastes. You’ve piqued my curiosity for sure.

    Like

  42. Chocolate dipped pie…oh my yes.

    Like

  43. Every of your recipes is amazing! This pie looks so perfect. First I thought it was a fod review for a commercially produced product. I’m sure it tastes much better though. It is really fantastic.

    Like

  44. That recipe is so unique! I would never imagine using avocado in that way. It’s worth a try for a get together to really shock guests when they hear the ingredients. I could have fun with it!

    Like

  45. Wow! Such a fantastic use of avocados. I’m in awe of the ones that are chocolate covered AND on a stick.

    Like

  46. pi-sicles you are a genius! lol

    those look so yummy and refreshing!

    Like

  47. OMG, I can’t tell you how awesome those pops look! If you sold them from a cart in downtown Austin you would be rich in one day!

    Like

  48. This looks perfect! I was just pushing the bottle of creme de menthe out of the way the other day (to get to the tequila) and thought, “I need to use this stuff up.” The avocado in this is brilliant too, color and creaminess!

    Like

  49. Okay you! I was hooked on just seeing the pie and then you have to go and cover it in chocolate and stick it in the freezer to make a pie-sicle. ohhhhhhhhhhh yummmmmmmmmm!

    Like

  50. How inventive and utterly mouth-watering!

    Like

  51. You just blew my mind!

    Like

  52. Wow, this looks way tooo good!

    Like

  53. Pie on a stick! Gasp. If I were wearing heels right now, I’d certainly be clicking them!

    Like

  54. Oh wowowow I love it! It looks so good!!!

    Like

  55. This looks incredible. I like the kid’s version! Great job!!

    Like

  56. What a strange name for a pie!

    The one thing I love about the pie’s recipe at a glace was that the green color came naturally from avocados! I made your red velvet cupcakes for the fourth of July, and I’ve made them many time before! I think it is just the amazing fact that the earth is so colorful!

    Enough about colors! I am curious about this pie. I’ve never heard of it. After I looked it up quickly on Google, I noticed how very un-vegan grasshopper pie is! So, CONGRATS on making what looked like an impossible un-vegan recipe in to a lovely natural vegan pie (and recipe!)! And covering it in chocolate! you’ve gone too far!

    I would love to get my hands on some vegan marshmallows!!! I am a semi-vegan, more vegan then vegetarian, now. But, once I found out what gelatin was, I freaked out! I find it hidden in so many things! I did manage to find Ricemellow. Which quickly turned into that favorite snake!

    Could you use ricemellow instead of the marshmallows? Like, with some thickener, cornstarch or agar-agar?

    Just wondering! :D

    LOVE

    Like

  57. Oh my gosh, YUM! I’d like mine on a stick, please.

    Like

  58. Dude, seriously, my two favorite things: avocados and grasshopper pie. You are making it very hard for me to stay on my diet! But I do so miss your sweet little amigurumi, they were so inspiring! I hope you get more time to craft soon!

    Like

  59. I’ve never had Grasshopper Pie before, but the flavor combination sounds yummy.

    By the way, I finally got a copy of your cookbook. I am so excited to start making things from it, everything in it looks delicious!

    Like

  60. that is too funny and tasty. I had forgotten all about grasshopper pie. of course you had to hit it out of the park by covering it in chocolate. well done!

    Like

  61. Tried this recipe over the weekend. By itself as a frozen pie, I thought the first bites definitely tasted of avocado (although by b/f didn’t), but you seem to get used to it after the initial flavor quandry. We went ahead and tried the magic shell topping + stick stepm and it rocketed it to a new level of deliciousness. So if you’re thinking about trying it, go ahead and do the extra step of chocolate dipping. Totally worth it! The chocolate crust adds a nice texture to it too.

    Like

  62. So yummy, I want to try it. A unique recipe you have, something like every people have to look for it. Really, I was amaze with the recipe you have in a pie, it was just like i’m speechless :). It was just like my favorite sweets before which I really want to have them back also. Excellent recipe, want to try this one at home. Have a nice day.

    Like

  63. I’m up for anything with mint, and especially anything named Grasshopper! It looks so good.

    Like

  64. My great aunts and uncles started a delicious cake and pie company years ago. Every family gathering featured their delicious treats. My favorites? Their carrot cake and grasshopper pie.

    These are honestly the only two things that could make me break vegan. I was recently considering taking their recipe and finding a way to make it vegan, but I figured it would lead to much disaster in the kitchen. I’m not the best when it comes to experimenting.

    I’m glad to see that you’ve made a vegan type of grasshopper pie! I’ll have to try this soon.

    thanks for the recipe!

    Like

  65. Oh my gosh! This looks so so yummy! Incredible!

    Like

  66. So I made this, using the soy+peppermint extract option. Two things: 1) don’t over process the mixture after adding the marshmallows, it will deflate the filling. 2) DO NOT forget to put this back in the fridge after you sneak a bite before heading to work in the morning. You will come home to mud-coloured pie.
    I added chocolate chips to mine, mini chips would have been better but it was really fantastic. I also used wafer cookies rather than oreo-type cookies.
    Thanks so much for the recipe!

    Like

  67. Pingback: Grasshopper Pie « Go Vegan Go!

  68. Pingback: Columbus Foodie » Blog Archive » July 2009 Roundup

  69. Actually, the name “grasshopper pie” is thought to come from a drink from the 1960s called the Grasshopper, which also featured mint as its primary flavor.

    But anyway, your use of avocado is ingenious, and the pie looks absolutely lovely!

    Like

  70. Wow! this is yummy! love it! thanks!

    Like

  71. How did you cut it up without the base crumbling?? I always have that problem! Looks gorgeous :)

    Like

  72. The first pic was impressive… mint-green pie, fluffy and creamy and delish. Then I scrolled down and recognized the dipped-in-chocolate-pie…. Pi-sicles…. I am just speechless, mouthwatering, gasping, speechless!

    Like

  73. A cremepie. Vegan. Covered in chocolate. on a stick? Are you kidding? Wow, this really looks amazing!!!

    Like

  74. Absolutely delicious

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s