An Obsession with All Things Handmade and Home-Cooked

Thoroughly Chilled


Cooking seasonally keeps things exciting; New produce to utilize and different flavors to play with. It gives the changing atmosphere much more purpose in my eyes, as every cold snap means another day to make a big pot of soup, and the fierce winds have me turning towards hot chocolate and chai. The downside, of course, is the need to let go of those beloved warm-weather dishes that were like close friends only a few short weeks ago. For some people, this means that the ice cream maker will be evicted from its spot in the freezer for another half year, sentenced to defrost in the darkness of a kitchen cabinet.

Well, if you ask me, that sort of behavior is just plain crazy, as I’m a firm believer in year-round ice cream enjoyment! Besides, if you put away that machine now, you’ll miss out on some of the best flavors that this season has to offer: Eggnog, candy cane, gingerbread, pumpkin spice… Put on a sweater and crank up the heat, because there’s no way the ice cream will stop churning out of my kitchen!

Easy as Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream

1 15-Ounce Can Pumpkin Puree
1 14-Ounce Can Coconut Milk
1 Cup Dark Brown Sugar, Packed
1/4 Cup Maple Syrup
2 Tablespoons Bourbon
2 Teaspoons Ground Cinnamon
1 Teaspoon Ground Ginger
1/4 Teaspoon Ground Cloves
Pinch Freshly Cracked Black Pepper
1/4 Teaspoon Salt
1 Teaspoon Vanilla Extract

Okay, now this is a real tough recipe, so are you ready? … Take all of the ingredients, and mix them together in a big bowl until smooth and homogeneous. Chill if not already cold, and process in your ice cream machine as per the manufacturer’s instructions. Transfer into an air-tight container and freeze until solid before serving. Whew! After all that work, this ice cream sure hits the spot!

PS: Not too keen on making a traditional pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving this year? Just make a batch of this ice cream, smooth it into a pre-baked graham cracker crust, and freeze until firm enough to slice. Perfect to make ahead of time, too!

Printable Recipe

Author: Hannah (BitterSweet)

Author of My Sweet Vegan, Vegan Desserts, Vegan a la Mode, and Easy as Vegan Pie.

68 thoughts on “Thoroughly Chilled

  1. uh, one 14-ounce cup of coconut milk? please fix–this sounds delish!!!!!! thanks!!!!!

  2. OH. MY. GOSH! I need to make this now!!!

  3. Yay! This looks incredible.

    It’s bizarre; I didn’t make ice cream all summer and now I’m craving it. I just made some this afternoon as a matter of fact. Ah, I guess it looks like I’m going to have to make some more…

  4. I’m sure I could get into ice cream like this one, even in winter! I love the idea of the pie, too.

  5. It looks fabulous, Hannah, and way better than pumpkin pie! Mmm, some little ginger cookies to go with it…..

  6. YUM. And I love the pie idea!!

  7. Holy Cow! Super Easy!!

  8. Sounds like a fabulous substitute for Pumpkin Pie.

  9. Oh man, perfect!!!!

    By the way, I just wanted to let you know, I made the next test recipe today and I’ll email it to you tomorrow!

  10. wowsa, guess what’s on my xmas list!

  11. hannah,
    i grew up off of pumpkin icecream pie, just as you describe. it was a staple on my street!


  12. I’m thinking cinnamon ice cream! I’d like to make it for Thanksgiving, my mother is a cinnamon fiend and would looove it!

  13. Yum, yum. I too just made some pumpkin ice cream as well. What a perfect looking scoop you got for your photo!

  14. Sounds so yummy – pumpkin icecream was my favourite holiday flavour when I was little!

  15. This must be a delicious ice cream!
    I see all these creative recipes with pumpkin in the blogosphere and still the only thing I do with it is roast it or make soup ;)

  16. I agree! Ice Cream should be eaten Year Round!!!

  17. gorgeous! I agree, who cares if it’s cold – you can’t beat homemade ice cream!!

  18. iced pumpkin pie? will you marry me?? :D

  19. this is a fantastic idea for thanksgiving! a break from tradition and some serious goodness. thanks!

  20. mmm pumpkin ice cream pumpkin pie with homemade magic shell.

  21. Amen to year round ice cream enjoyment! The color is stunning and the recipe sounds mouthwatering!

  22. i wish i had an ice cream maker!! and of COURSE ice cream is a year round thing. i mean…peppermint ice cream? hello! by the way, don’t feel bad about my bad clove experience. i think i’m going to add some cinnamon and nutmeg and see what happens. my tastebuds are just silly, don’t worry :)

  23. i too am a firm believer in year-round ice cream enjoyment! hoooooooray!

    now all i need to do is find an ice cream maker! i think i need to hurry up and get one (maybe i’ll see if i can get one for christmas) ’cause i neeeeeed to make your ice cream as soon as i can! squeeeeeee!

  24. I am definitely trying this! I love ice cream, no matter what time of year it is, and I love pumpkin. I never had pumpkin ice cream before, but I bet it’s really good.

  25. This looks amazing! Is there anything we could use in place of the coconut milk? You won’t believe this…coconut milk gives me a migraine. (Such a shame – I had to cut way back on my consumption of Thai food, which I love.) If heavy cream would work, I’m totally making this! :)

  26. I’m with you! A definite believer in ice cream year round!

  27. I love my ice cream all year round too. This sounds delicious, and I am actually planning on making a Christmas ice cream batch ! Cool

  28. Oh my goodness…that looks insanely good.

  29. wow this looks so decadent. i’ve only tried store bought pumpkin ice cream. i think it was edy’s but i practically gagged when i tasted it. this sounds so much better!

  30. This sounds great–love how you’re getting some rich creaminess from the coconut. Great idea!

  31. Frozen pumpkin pie, yum!

  32. I am so excited!
    We got a icecream maker. Ialways push for a vegan ice cream but my family would only let me do this every other weekend. Somekind of deal I made with them.
    Well, I don’t remember the last time we pulled it out. With extra cans of pumpkin needing to be used and a lonely ice cream maker, the match will be perfect!
    Perfect meaning- rich and creamy!
    I’ve just got to see if the family approves of such a friendly thought!

  33. I am going to make pumpkin pie. Sounds so good. mmm.

  34. Wow! i can’t wait to have this for Thanksgiving!

  35. OMG! Wow, delicious looking ice cream. Oh how I wish I could have a taste. Great job Hannah! :)

  36. Ooh, fabulous! I am an equal season opportunity ice cream lover!


  38. I love the ice cream pie idea! Yum!

  39. Season foods and flavors make me so happy. I bet in about 4 months i’ll be dying for a nice light fruit salad… hmm I wonder where i put my ice cream maker :)

  40. Yum yum yum! Pumpkin ice cream= my fav!

  41. Hi Hannah,
    My daughter Molly made your pumpkin ice cream. She and my hubby are both lactose intolerant, so all your lovely dairy free recipes are great at our house! The ice cream is terrific! Molly is having another bowl, as we speak!
    Yum, yum!

  42. oh this looks so incredible… I’m dying to get an ice cream maker!!!! I put it on my Christmas list, and also with a pair of new sneakers .. to counteract the ice cream maker.. lol

  43. !!!!
    i don’t even know what to say, except i want that RIGHT NOW.

  44. Honestly, Hannah, you never cease to amaze me with your creativity! I love the bourbon & pepper pinch in the ice cream and frozen pumpkin pie? Genius!

  45. Oh freaking WOW! I am sooooo making this!

  46. I need to get and ice cream maker so I can try this!!

    Thank you for sharing this recipe!

  47. ohhh yummy…I love pumpkin and to have it in ice cream is like frosting on a cake…. :)

  48. Ok, you’ve convince me. I’m not defrosting my ice cream maker insert! Those flavors sounds delicious for winter, and the pumpkin pie version sounds perfect!

  49. Sounds delicious!! I don’t want to buy a whole bottle of bourbon just for two tablespoons though… is there something we can substitute with? Or does it taste just fine without?

  50. I have been telling myself for weeks that I needed to make a pumpkin ice cream… you must have heard my littl prayer for a recipe!

  51. You know, I don’t think I have ever had pumpkin ice cream… Hard to believe, as I love everything pumpkin! I really must try this. It definitely doesn’t need to be hot outside for me to enjoy ice cream… I’ll take it any time!

  52. Wow – pumpkin ice-cream pie – that’s such a good idea!

  53. I just had some dairy pumpkin ice cream the other day and wanted to come up with a dairy-free version to make for my son (who loves pumpkin). We’ll be making this really soon!

  54. whoa. sounds great. I love the frozen ice cream pie idea. Sigh… so many calories, so little enthusiasm for exercise!

  55. I made this today (minus the bourbon since I didn’t have any on hand) and it was really delicious. I think I’ll have to take my ice cream maker with me to Thanksgiving at my sister’s house so everyone can have some.

  56. Looks yummy and the combination of coconut milk, spices and pumpkin puree sounds good!

  57. Hannah- I made for dessert today. It was delicious!!!

  58. Pingback: I scream for Ice Cream! | Vegan and The Beast

  59. I made this for my Vegan son the other day. The only change that I made is adding about half a handful of crystallized ginger during the last few minutes of freezing. I also admit that I didn’t measure the spices I don’t like to measure and you can’t make me.

    For some reason it froze into a solid mass in the freezer. I am sure I didn’t leave it in the ice cream maker long enough or something like that.

    It was a bit too pumpkiny for me but son liked it despite it being a frozen block.

  60. This just might be the best thing I’ve ever tasted. ‘nuf said. Thank you for the recipe!

  61. I love this ice cream, thank you for the recipe. I put in bits of graham cracker (pie needs crust!) and I love it. Also, I pre-chill my coconut milk and pumpkin before I mix everything together so I don’t have to wait to put it in the ice cream maker.

  62. Pingback: Pumpkin Spice Affogato | vegga

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s